Who Takes Garage Sale Leftovers

Have you ever cleaned out your basement or garage, held a garage sale, and then been left with a pile of items that didn’t sell?

Or have you been to a garage sale and noticed there were items left over at the end of the day?

So, who takes garage sale leftovers?

Do they get donated to charity? Do they get thrown away?

Every answer and idea you need will be found below.

Read More: What Is Thrifting?

TL;DR who takes garage sale leftovers

  • Donating unwanted items to charitable organizations is a great way to declutter and give back to the community. Plus, you may be able to claim a tax deduction.
  • Consignment stores and online marketplaces can be good options for selling higher-quality unsold items. Just be sure to carefully read the terms and conditions before leaving your items.
  • Local buy-back stores may be willing to pay cash for certain types of items, but they will likely offer significantly less than the original retail price.
  • Estate sales can be a good way to sell a large number of high-quality items. However, they are typically more expensive and time-consuming to organize than a garage sale.
  • Some leftover garage sale items may end up in landfills if they are not properly disposed of, especially if the items are not in good condition.

Related: How to thrift vintage online & What does thrift mean?


Possibly the best way back to the community and get a tax deduction while you’re at it by donating your leftover garage sale items to local charities!

Goodwill, Salvation Army, and local thrift stores are more than happy to accept gently used donations that can then be resold in their donation centers.

Not only will this help declutter your home but all proceeds benefit the charity’s mission, what could be better?

Many charities even offer free donation pickup service so disposing of unwanted possessions is easier than ever before.

Consignment Stores

If you’re looking for an alternative to disposing of your garage sale leftovers, consignment stores are the way to go.

Also known as consignment shops, these establishments specialize in dealing with pre-owned items that they can sell with higher price tags than most thrift shops.

If you want to turn a profit off of your top-notch, high-end goods that didn’t move at your garage sale, consider entrusting them in the care of a consignment store.

The store will help sell those items for you and give you a cut from the cost. However, before leaving any goods with the shop make sure to read their contract thoroughly!

With this strategy, not only can you recoup some of what was spent on these items but also potentially earn extra money as well.

Online Marketplaces

Thanks to the digital era, selling your yard sale leftovers on the internet has become much simpler than ever before.

You can reach a broader public using websites like eBay, Poshmark and Depop. Additionally, you may list them in local Facebook exchange clubs or Nextdoor’s community application.

I really like eBay if you want to sell a lot of items. You can learn how to sell on eBay and maybe make a business out of it.

You should be sure to set reasonable rates for each item and create precise descriptions with pictures of whatever you’re trying to sell if you want buyers’ attention.

Furthermore, don’t forget that exclusive products are best sold through an online marketplace (Things like sports equipment)!

Local Buy-Back Stores

Don’t let yourself get bogged down by the inconvenience of selling your pre-owned items if you did not have a successful garage sale.

It’s a good idea to consider taking them to a local buy-back store and you could receive cash on the spot for electronics, DVDs, CDs, and more! Note that they will likely offer less than the original retail price but it’s still worth looking into if you’d prefer not to go through the hassle of doing it all yourself.

Recycling Centers

If the objects left over from your spring cleaning are beyond selling or donating, you could be forced to throw them away.

Fortunately, many cities have recycling centers that accept large waste items in exchange for a fee.

Although this avenue won’t bring back any money and some of these facilities may ask to separate out recyclable products from non-recyclables, which can take time, it’s still worth considering as an alternative to sending those materials straight into an overcrowded landfill (more on that later).

Estate Sales

Are you drowning in leftover garage sale items? Is your house feeling cluttered and overwhelming?

If you’re downsizing or moving, an estate sale may be the perfect solution to help you get rid of a vast selection of items.

Unlike regular garage sales, estate sales are typically more comprehensive and organized.

Instead of spending hours pricing and advertising your items, you can sit back and relax while a professional estate liquidation company takes care of all the details.

But the benefits of an estate sale don’t stop there.

If you have high-end, valuable items that didn’t sell at your garage sale, an estate sale is a perfect opportunity to get them in front of potential buyers.

With a wider audience and the expertise of a professional team, you may be able to fetch a higher price for your items.

Rummage Sale

A rummage sale is a type of sale, similar to a garage sale, where people sell a variety of items, including clothing, household goods, and small appliances.

Rummage sales are often organized by charitable organizations, churches, or schools as a way to raise money for a specific cause.

They can be held indoors or outdoors, and items are typically priced at a lower cost than at a traditional retail store.

Rummage sales are a great way to find unique or gently used items at a lower price, and they can also be a fun way to spend a Saturday morning hunting for treasures.

If you have leftover items from a garage sale, you may be able to donate them to a local rummage sale to help raise funds for a good cause.


Regrettably, not all leftover garage sale items find their new owners.

Some people may decide to discard them out of sheer laziness or lack of storage space rather than finding a way to donate them.

As such, these discarded objects contribute to needless waste in landfills and can have serious environmental consequences.

Other Options

There are many other options for getting rid of leftover garage sale items. You can try selling them at a flea market or hosting your own yard sale.

You can also ask family members or friends if they are interested in taking any of the items off your hands. Some people even put up flyers or advertise in classified ads to find new homes for their leftover items.

The Bottom Line

If you happen to have any items left over after a garage sale, there are multiple solutions available instead of disposing of them.

For instance, donations can be made to charitable organizations or they may even be sold on online marketplaces, allowing these leftovers the chance of being reused rather than ending up in landfills.

So, consider one of these options next time you find yourself with some extra goods!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *